I haven't tried the Smashbox one but did try my sister's PH matchmaker version. I personally didn't like the color that developed, on me, but it looks great on her. Just FYI- I am uber pale, as in lily white but with neutral undertones, with a lot of pigment in my lips naturally. This came out looking kinda "freaky". Although it was supposed to turn a "light pink", it came out ultra bright fuschia on me. My sister has a deeper, more "medium" skin tone that is more warm and it comes up a gorgeous rosy-pink on her. Hope this helps!

Very interesting. It's too bad you can't sample products in CVS :( -TBDatabaseAbigail