Glad I helped! LOL I think I may have tried just about every BB cream I've been able to actually get my hands on...being fair, I'm sure you can relate! Everything must be tried on the skin. What texture are you looking for? For shades- what is your predominant undertone? I am more neutral but if I have to call it, I lean towards a cooler undertone. So far, the best color matches for me have been Palmer's Eventone BB cream (believe it or not and I have reviewed it on TB) in the lightest shade (very impressive product too....more actual "good for you" skin care ingredients then most of the others and not too sheer) and the new Tarte BB tinted primer. The worst ones have been L'oreal Magic Skin Beautifier BB cream which turned as orange as a tangerine on my face within 10 minutes and the Garnier Skin Renew BB cream, prior to them launching a shade in fair which I haven't yet been brave enough to try. LOL The "lightest" shade they had at the time was also very orange on me.

Just a note to anyone checking out these products- if you're very fair, like me, these are NOT for you. They're no where near light enough for a true fair skin and they're also overly yellow based. Just wanted to put that out there........

Thank you! I'm still searching for a BB cream with the "right" texture and color. You've just saved me money--I like Physician's Formula products but am quite fair.

Yes jenn, your post has been helpful to me too! L'oreal owns Garnier, so I am not suprised to hear you had the same experience with both. I look at their products and none of them interest me - at all. I am going to go check out your BB reviews now... :)