Hi, I discovered and LOVE Blinc! It stays on until you take it off with warm rubbing and gentle rubbing.

Most waterproof makeup removers are made with the double layer (like the oil and the colored liquid), those are the best at removing mascara. They also condition your lashes to make them stronger, especially since waterproof mascara can kind of dry your lashes out. The most important thing when removing is to saturate the cotton ball and place it on your eye for about five to ten seconds before you wipe it off; this way it will break down all of the makeup and it will come off quicker. You don't want to just immediately wipe it off because that will likely rip out more of your lashes.

I use a waterproof mascara most of the year because it just stays put better. Right now I'm using Cover Girl Lash Blast waterproof in Very Black (orange tube). It's working great! Not a fan of the Blinc mascara but glad it works for some!

I bought one, the Maybelline The Falsies Volum' Express one, and it's a fantastic waterproof mascara, but like you said, it's just so hard to remove and it makes some of my lashes fall out which is a big, big no-no xoxo

My new favorite for the past week is Make Up For Ever Aqua Smokey lash. LOVE LOVE LOVE this!!!

MUFE aqua smokey lash or covergirl lashblast waterproof. Even though they are so difficult to remove!

Every once in awhile I use a lash ink instead of waterproof mascara. It's pretty much an extremely waterproof mascara that stays on for three days. It's good for the summer when you're swimming a lot or at the beach

I do not like waterproof products, the mascaras are hardly removed, they need a lot of rubbing which ends with some lash breakage. I just get regular mascaras, Maybelline ones are pretty good deal, good quality at affordable price.

My new favorite for the past week is Make Up For Ever Aqua Smokey lash. LOVE LOVE LOVE this!!!

I occasionally use colossal lash water proof, but I use it super rarely. Waterproof mascara tends to be goopy and never comes off. I prefer to use a mascara primer (estee lauder and lancome are really good) for long lasting makeup.