You've been through the gamut when it comes to products. I would suggest that you purchase a Clarisonic or Personal Microdermabrasion Device to deeply clean and rid you of the the scars you have. I find that staying with one company's regimen is best: Neutrogena has supreme products, but maybe you want to look at Ole Henriksen. My skin is in good shape (thank God!), but when I t received a sample of Ole Henriksen's best-selling products from Sephora, I saw how they work in tandem against both blemishes and wrinkles, imparting a new luminosity and clarity. The fruit acids in this line help to lighten scars and corrrect oily areas. Ole Henriksen himself suffered from cystic acne; he went on to model, school himself, and create his own line of amazing, truly beneficial products. I'm still a believer in "the less you handle your skin the better" when it comes to aging. Perhaps this line will help you. I find it awesome! Please let me know if I can help you with anything else!

Please let me know how you are doing!