I love "Physicians Formula Eye Booster - 2-in-1 Lash Boosting Eyeliner + Serum" (less than $10.00 in drugstores). It glides on very easily; I can get a fine line when I can't with other products. You don't have to line the bottom, but I do because I can use the definition. Let me know if you have any questions--good luck!

Physician's Formula cannot be beaten! It glides on effortlessly, stays put for twenty-four hours, and nourishes the eye area.

The best liquid eyeliner is by Sephora. It is only 12 dollars and the color it comes in are gorgeous!

I love Line Stiletto by Maybelline

I love Line Stiletto by Maybelline

I love this liner and can't get enough.

I really am loving wet n wilds mega liner in black it does not go anywhere once its applied and the brush is great for creating that super precise wing. The price point is amazing I believe I pay $1.99 for it at my local drugstore. Definitely recommend it!!! Hope this helps.

I would recommend the Wet N Wild Mega Liner. Super easy to use, thin formula, brush tip. I love it, and it's around $2. I'm still practicing a wing tip and haven't achieved it yet, but search YouTube and there's great tutorials on it. I recommend EmilyNoel83. She's awesome. I don't line my bottom line with eyeliner since it smudges on me, so I use a dark shadow. Hope this helps.

Maybelline Eye Studio Master Precise Ink Pen Eyeliner is the best for me! I sometimes do my lower lash line when doing a cat eye, I will connect the top and bottom at the end of my eye and do a swoop upward, It really is a dramatic look. For a less dramatic look just do you're top and draw the wing out and upward. It takes lot's of practice I have been using liquid liner since the 90's :) I can now do it in less than 5 minutes! The Physicians Formula Eye Booster is second best for me, keep practicing!

I am a big fan of Eyeko's liquis liner. It resembles a marker but it is the darkest and it stays put.